Great Eats in Treasure Island

For such a small place, Treasure Island packs a big punch, and that includes incredible places to eat. Whether visitors are arriving in Treasure Island for the first time or it’s their favorite vacation spot, there are certain go-to spots that serve up the most delicious meals and give off the perfect vibe. Can’t decide where to start? Treasure Island has an eatery for every taste and preference, but here are six fantastic can’t-miss choices.

Surf Meets Turf at Middle Grounds Grill 

Middle Grounds Grill is a family-owned restaurant offering incredible surf and turf options. Middle Grounds Grill is a tasty way to experience local seafood at its freshest by combining an upscale look with a family-friendly menu and ambiance. Because this destination is so popular, reservations are strongly recommended.

Simple Is Best at The Floridian  

There’s an art to crafting the perfect Cuban sandwich, and The Floridian has mastered it. Visitors rub elbows with lifelong locals at The Floridian on the open-air deck or in the indoor dining area. Call ahead and place a large order to go for a memorable sandwich experience on a beach trip or at a party.

VIP in Demand 

For a fun change, head over to VIP for tasty eats and drinks. The masterminds at VIP have put together a menu that combines the flavors of Mexico with the laid-back vibe of Treasure Island, Florida. The only difficulty will be in deciding what to choose. Dine-in for a party atmosphere, enjoying fresh-made salsa, guacamole, and more. There are no reservations—it’s strictly first-come, first-serve!

Relax at Caddy’s 

There are several Caddy’s locations now, but the original is still on Sunset Beach in Treasure Island. Caddy’s offers one-of-a-kind specials and delicious barbecue, but it also provides an experience. People go to Caddy’s not just for the food but also for live music, peaceful cabanas on the beach, and even for yoga sessions. Time slows down for visitors at Caddy’s.

Sip at Sea Dog Brewery 

Breweries are all the rage these days, and Sea Dog brings Maine-brewed flavors to the Florida Gulf for a unique handcrafted beer experience. With flavors like apricot, wild blueberry, and hazelnut porter, Sea Dog offers a memorable small-batch brewery experience. In addition to seasonal flavors, there’s also a full menu with outstanding flavors that hold their own.

Classic Comfort at Gigi’s Italian Restaurant 

Gigi’s is a family-owned restaurant that brings the traditional Italian restaurant atmosphere with checkered tablecloths and candlelit dinners to Treasure Island. For more than 52 years, Gigi’s has served antipasto, pizzas, veal parmigiana, and other Italian comfort food favorites. Gigi’s rates highly among visitors and locals alike for turning out the best Italian on the beach for decades.

Hungry for the Best 

To get the most out of a vacation, explore new tastes and experiences. Treasure Island offers more than its fair share of top-tier restaurants and eateries. Visitors can find food that feeds the body and nourishes the soul while making unforgettable memories. Explore new menu items, exciting flavors, and unique atmospheres at six of Treasure Island’s best dining spots. Everyone is sure to find a dining option that will perfectly complement their vacation. To find out more about our top Treasure Island dining picks or to explore even more, call us!